June 13, 2022
Belgian telecoms operator Proximus NV provides two Belgian electronic directories, www.1207.be and www.1307.be and two directory enquiry services, 1207 and 1307. Proximus includes the contact details of its own subscribers, as well as those from other telecoms operators, in these directories. It also passes the contact details on to other directory providers.
A subscriber to another telecoms operator in Belgium called Telenet, which does not provide directories itself but gives its subscriber contact details to other operators, including Proximus, complained to the Belgian Data Protection Authority (DPA) when his contact details were included in Proximus’s directories and directory enquiry services despite him having contacted Proximus directly via its website asking for his details not to be included.
The DPA found in favour of the complainant and ordered Proximus to comply with the personal data processing rules under the GDPR. Proximus appealed to the Belgian Court of Appeal, which asked the CJEU whether Articles 12(2) and 2(f) of the Privacy Directive (2002/58/EC) read in conjunction with Article 95 of the GDPR (2016/679/EU) meant that a national supervisory authority (NSA) must gain a subscriber’s consent pursuant to the GDPR in order to publish contact details in directories in the absence of national legislation to the contrary.
Advocate General Collins has opined that consent, as defined in Article 4(11) of the GDPR, is required for a telecoms operator to include a data subject’s contact details in directories, whether published by a telecoms operator or by other directory providers.
Further, the AG said that a request by a subscriber to have his or her data removed from directories constitutes an exercise of “the right to erasure” under Article 17 of the GDPR and that, pursuant to Articles 5(2) and 24 of the GDPR, an NSA can conclude that the data controller has to take appropriate technical and organisational measures to inform third-party controllers, i.e. the telecoms operator and other providers of directories that have received data from the first controller, of the withdrawal of the subscriber’s consent in accordance with Articles 6 and 7 of the GDPR.
Finally, the AG said that the GDPR does not preclude an NSA from ordering a provider of directories to inform search engine providers of requests for erasure that it has received. (Case C-129/21 Proximus NV (Public electronic directories) v Gegevensbeschermingsautoriteit EU:C:2022:332 (28 April 2022) — to read the judgment in full, click here).
Expertise